Tonight’s Big ‘Supergirl’ Reveal. No, Not That One. The Other One. (Spoilers)

VANAPHASE™ the Vanadium powerhouse!

There will be spoilers ahead, especially for West Coast viewers who have yet to see tonight’s episode. Though I’ve tried my hardest to put a bit of space between you and the spoileriest photo that ever spoilered, you have been warned.

If you watch Supergirl regularly, then tonight’s episode, for many of you at least, was a bit of a shocker. And I’m not talking about the revelation that…

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

|

Hank Henshaw was this guy all along.

So yeah, that happened. Henshaw in the comics becomes Cyborg Superman, and that’s what many of us were expecting. The red glowing eyes in an earlier episode keeping that fact in our thoughts. And then, nope. J’onn J’onnz. What a great twist that still leaves the possibility of Cyborg Superman appearing as a possibility. Fans went crazy on social media, many not because of the reveal but in how they found out about it. In fact, many only found out by careless or thoughtless comic “news” websites posting articles on Facebook with the spoiler right there in the title. One even had an accompanying photo, just in case the reader skimmed the title and missed it. Shame on you for that. And yeah, that’s a pretty cool reveal, that I for one didn’t see coming. But it’s not the revelation I want to talk about.

Tonight’s episode of Supergirl listed creator credits, which is a good thing. The creators of all of these characters deserve to have the viewers know their names, and that people put in the work of not only creating them, but of giving them life, and giving the television networks and studios something to put on the screen. So it was nice to see Siegel and Shuster get the recognition they deserve.

credits

Except they didn’t create Supergirl. They created SuperMAN, two decades earlier. No, Supergirl was the creation of Otto Binder and Al Plastino first as Super-Girl in 1958 in Superman issue #123, and as Supergirl almost a year later in Action Comics #252. So why do Siegel and Shuster receive credit when they didn’t create the character? Well, that comes down to the way DC Comics defines “creation”. Gerry Conway was the first to show the fans and those outside the industry how DC handles their Royalty System in a blog post six months ago entitled Who created Caitlin Snow on #TheFlash? According to @DCComics, nobody.

It seems, once Paul Levitz left DC as Publisher of DC Comics, and DC became DC Entertainment, things changed in how the royalty system would work going forward. Conway received a letter from DC Entertainment’s new President, Diane Nelson, informing him that he is no longer entitled to equity payments for Power Girl, as DC has decided she is a derivative of Supergirl, who was derived from Superman, and technically wasn’t created by anybody because she already existed? It’s an interesting, if not baffling read as Conway lays out the details of how DC decides if something is derivative or original creation. He continues…

The next thing I learned about DC Entertainment’s new approach to their comic creators equity program was just as distressing, given how many characters I created for DC over the decade-plus I wrote for the company: if I wanted to receive an equity participation contract for a character I created, I had to request one, in writing, for each character, before that character appeared in another media, because DC would refuse to make equity payments retroactively.

So DC wouldn’t pay their creators royalties on characters they created unless the creators requested it? This seems like a strange and backwards way for a corporation to work, unfortunately it’s not. Conway estimates that he probaly created more then 500 characters during his time at DC in the 70s and 80s, many of them minor characters who only appeared in a handful of books, others only making a single appearance. How is a guy supposed to remember all of them three decades plus later? And how is he supposed to know that one might take on an all new life on television, such as Arrow‘s Felicity Smoak? But there’s more.

Even if Conway, or any creator, spent the time and effort to track down every character they ever created AND fill out the request forms, DC could still decide that the character or characters are derivative of another earlier creation, and therefore the creator is owed nothing. DC, and Marvel, and others, have never had the best creator credit track record, but this? This is a crazy length to go to deny creators their due.

What, exactly, is DC’s definition of a “derivative” character?

It’s a character that DC decides was “derived” from some other previously existing character.

For example, Power Girl– “derived” from Superman, because, like Supergirl, she’s a relative of Superman. Which means I can’t claim to be her co-creator because Superman is a pre-existing character. Fair enough, I suppose. The logic here is that Superman is the original creation, so Power Girl is derived from that original creation, so in effect, Power Girl is an extension of Superman, which means, by this tortured logic, that Power Girl was more or less created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster.

Which brings us to tonight’s episode of Supergirl. And the Siegel and Shuster creator credit. Many websites, some you may visit, have written about DC’s “derivative” definition and how it affects creators when it comes to royalties. Even I had previously touched upon it. But few of us saw this one coming. Much like the reveal of our green friend up above. It’s nice that DC and the people behind Supergirl are giving creators credit at the beginning of the show, but they’re giving the wrong creators credit. Even as weird as the policy is, I kind of get it, in a greedy, corporate way of thinking. Wait, no I don’t. I don’t think like that. I like to give people their due.

So I propose a compromise. People obviously connect Superman and Supergirl. Right? They both have the big red “S” on their chests, which is kind of a dead giveaway they’re connected. Why not have a “Superman created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster” credit followed up by a “Supergirl created by Otto Binder and Al Plastino” credit. It’s win win, right? Wrong. Because then they’d have to give “equity payments” to the estates of four creators instead of two. And that’s just not good business.

Now don’t get me wrong, the comic industry has made leaps and bounds in creator rights over the decades, thanks to popular, outspoken creators using their power at the time to make a stand for others. Social media has also made the industry smaller as well, allowing the fans a better look into publishers’ practices, putting more pressure on them to do the right thing. And many on the inside are working to get creators the rights, credit, and royalties they deserve. Oh, and Gerry Conway kind of apologized to Geoff Johns, Dan DiDio, Jim Lee, and Larry Ganem for that blog post because they are championing creator rights at DC. We’ve come a long way, but there’s still a distance to go, as shown in the opening credits of tonight’s Supergirl.

 

Oh, and Martian Manhunter FTW!!!!!1!!!!!

 

YogaOutlet.com

Leave a Reply

Animation/Anime Interviews Animation/Anime News Animation/Anime Reviews Film/TV Interviews Film/TV News Film/TV Review
The Happytime Murders Trailer
A Very NSFW Trailer for the Puppet Raunch-Fest of ‘The Happytime Murders’

How in the world does The Happytime Murders exist? This upcoming...

First Reformed
Paul Schrader’s ‘First Reformed’ is a Haunting, Powerful Drama

“Can God forgive us?” is a question asked in various ways...

Die Hard Blu-ray
‘Die Hard’ Gets a 4K Upgrade for its 30th Anniversary

One of the greats of the action genre, John McTiernan’s Die...

Enabled Gaming Gaming News Gaming Reviews
Coffee Crisis Interview with C# Developer Nick Mann

Check out our Coffee Crisis Interview with C# Developer Nick Mann...

A World’s First by Worlds Adrift! – Launching on Early Access

Upcoming PC game, Worlds Adrift, is launching players into the sky...

First Major Hunt: Showdown Content Update Now Live On Steam

The first major Hunt: Showdown content update is now live on Steam and...

Comic Creator Interviews Comic/Graphic Novel News Comic/Graphic Novel Reviews Manga News Manga Reviews Novel/Novella Author Interviews Novel/Novella News Novel/Novella Reviews
Action Comics No. 1000 gets a Super-Sized Deluxe Edition Release

From DC Comics – Burbank, CA – (April 30, 2018) –...

7.5/10
‘The Prisoner #1’ is an Intricate and Entertaining Tale of Intrigue

The Prisoner #1 Story by: Peter Milligan Art by: Colin Lorimer Coloring by: Joana...

Comic Legend Stan Lee Sued Over Sexual Misconduct Allegations by Massage Therapist

From Canyon PR – CHICAGO – Apr. 23, 2018 – Maria...

Apparel/Personal Maintenance News Apparel/Personal Maintenance Reviews Entertainment Product News Entertainment Product Reviews Food/Beverage Reviews Hardware News Hardware Reviews Mystery Box News Mystery Box Reviews
Work-Play Lens
High-Tech Meets High Fashion in GUNNAR Optiks New Work-Play Lens

GUNNAR Optiks partners with Publish to release new Work-Play Lens that...

Keep Your Gear from Not Feeling So Good – Infinity War Skins Review

Skinit goes for the head with their Avengers: Infinity War skins –...

Spring/Summer 2018: adidas Sports Updates Line of Mobile Accessories

April 2018 — adidas Sport launches collection of lightweight products designed to...

Arena Football Automotives MMA, Kick Boxing & Boxing Professional Wrestling
Showtime to Air ‘Bipolar Rock ‘N’ Roller’ Mauro Ranallo Doc on May 25th

From Bellator MMA and Showtime – New York – April 30,...

Bas Rutten Talks Kicking Opioid Addiction with the Help of Receptra CBD Oil

  One of the most decorated MMA champions and UFC Hall...

Roxy Astor Meets With GLOW…the Netflix Version

As much as people love drama, there was nothing but love...

Adult Continuity Comics on the Can Cultural Junk Drawer Future Comic Rock Stars Is That Racist? Revisiting the Reviled THAT'S NOT ROTTEN! The B-Reel The Cantina Scene This Week in Crowdfunding What the HELL Did I just...?
Adult Continuity Issue #13 – Avengers XXX – A porn parody

I review AvengersXXX and make masturbation jokes. Be smart with your Fapdollar(tm);...

Comics on the can – Black Panther (Priest run) Issue #46

Comics on the can muses about Black Panther during Priest's legendary...

MissionFest Wine, Craft Beer and Food Festival Takes Place 4th of July Weekend

MissionFest™ Wine, Craft Beer, Food and Music Festivals, combines two great...

Event News Event Reviews
The Music Tastes Good Volume III Line Up Has Been Announced

Music Tastes Good Volume III, presented by 89.9 KCRW, Line Up has...

free comic book day
Free Manga from VIZ Media for Free Comic Book Day

TLDR: VIZ Media will provide free manga samplers on Free Comic...

Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure Escape Room Comes to America!

TLDR: CRAP Entertainment and Viz Media, LLC partnered with Real Escape...

Gaming Uncensored Toon-In-Talk
Gaming Uncensored: Year in Review 2016

A look back at the year in gaming. Related

Gaming Uncensored Roundtable: December 2016

December’s roundtable discusses story in games with Chad, Josh, and Spencer....

Gaming Uncensored: Podcast #349

Jamie reflects on some of his time with the HTC Vive....

Music Interviews Music News Music Reviews
Rising Country Music Artist Kaylin Roberson Talks About her work with St. Jude

Kaylin Roberson is a singer, songwriter and pianist from Raleigh, North...

MTV Unveils Performers for ‘TRL Live’ on October 3rd at 3 p.m. E.T.

NEW YORK, NY (September 26, 2017) – MTV today announced that...

Long Beach Punk Band ‘Spider’ Rocks ‘It’s Not Dead’ Festival

Spider is a heavy hitting punk band out of Long Beach,...

%d bloggers like this: