Chip Zdarsky vs The Harvey Awards – A Different Kind of Battle for Inclusion in Comics Continues

VANAPHASE™ the Vanadium powerhouse!


I’ve never been a fan of awards shows, as to me they’ve always seemed like a popularity contest. I have a love/hate relationship with comics awards shows; I like seeing creators I love being recognized for their work, but a lot of the time these even feel like popularity contests. This year there have been some minor scandals/controversy/social complications surrounding awards shows. The Hugo Awards this year were controversial, but I won’t elaborate further because so many others already have. This was a battle for inclusion, and now we have warning shot in a different battle for inclusion facing the Harvey Awards.

It seems that Chip Zdarsky (Howard the Duck, some other stuff… probably) won the Special Award for Humor for his work on Sex Criminals. And he isn’t happy. He wrote about his displeasure in July when his nomination was first announced, and explained why he was displeased. And now he’s writing about it again. Sure Chip’s work on Sex Crimz is bloody brilliant, but here’s the thing: Sex Criminals is a collaboration between Chip and Matt Fraction. It has been since the very beginning. Yet Chip’s was the only name on the ballot for some reason.

sex-criminalsHe explained in July that unless this was changed he would not be accepting the award should he win. He contacted the organizers and asked that the nomination should be changed to “Chip Zdarsky and Matt Fraption, SEX CRIMINALS, Image Comics”, and barring that he asked for his name to be withheld from the ballot entirely. He stated in a blog entry posted today:

The fact that I was nominated for a humor award for SEX CRIMINALS without the writer of said series, my beloved chum, Matt Fraction, is wrong. On every level. I pointed this out to the Harvey Awards and told them I wished to have Matt on the ballot with me, or to remove me completely, and they declined to do either.

They said, and I quote; “We believe any collaborative process which the creators believe is equally divided makes this difficult.  It’s unfortunate this is not a judgment call for us to make – but it’s not.”

Except for the fact that it is. They created a category designed to highlight individuals, sometimes out of a team, with no recognition of what has been contributed and by whom. The writer of our comic supplies 90% of the humor! This is the Harvey Awards’s category, so the ultimate judgement call is theirs.

As the book’s writer, Matt Fraction supplies much of the humor, with Chip being Chip and making the funny pictures. Some may view this as a whiny creator blah blah blah, but he has a very valid point. Comics are a collaborative medium at their core, with writers, pencilers, inkers, colorists, and letterers, not to mention editors, all adding something to the finished product. Would Sex Criminals still be a funny book with just Chip on board? Probably, as he’s a hilarious writer as well as artist. Would it be AS funny? Almost certainly not. There are few comics out there that benefit from collaboration the way Sex Criminals does, from the story to the marketing.

And it isn’t even really about the collaboration itself, but the credit. Every person who contributes something to a comic, or a movie or television show, deserves to have their work credited. It’s only been a number of years since inkers and colorists were given cover credits, and some publishers don’t even do that. In very few instances I’ve even seen a letterer’s name on a cover, which is good, but doesn’t happen nearly enough. It’s long been the norm to only provide the names of the writer and artist on a comic cover or hardcover spine, but many other times one or the other is eliminated for whatever reason.

Chip Zdarsky’s protest will hopefully bring attention to this issue, not that others haven’t tried before. But what he proposes, while small in the grand scheme of things, is eminently doable:

I put forth the idea to the Harveys that the category simply be changed in the future to “Best Humor Publication,” in order to recognize the end result, instead of imagining who contributed what in a team effort. They could do that or just keep the nominations to creators who do all the work on their books, like Ryan Browne or Kate Beaton. They never responded to me, so I’m putting this idea out to you, the people who vote and are voted on. In an industry that daily has to contend with lopsided credits in the media, how can we allow ourselves to contribute to it with this award? Let’s make this category reflect the teams who deserve it.

So those of you who CAN vote, use your voice to change things, even in this small way. Wars are only won battle by battle, and this skirmish can have far-reaching repercussions. In fact, why not hit publisher, the media, conventions, and awards shows on multiple fronts? Use email and social media to let them know that it’s okay to recognize all of the creators involved in a project, and in fact is a welcome and refreshing idea. The comic industry is evolving, slowly yet surely; let’s give it a gentle nudge to help it along. Chip finishes his post with this classy gem:

Until then, I can’t accept the award. I love the people who voted for me, but I can’t abide by the rules set in place to allow such a thing. If, for some reason, it’s already en route to me, I’ll just carve Matt’s name into it and raffle it off for the HERO INITIATIVE.

Brimp on, Chip. Brimp on.

Leave a Reply

Animation/Anime Interviews Animation/Anime News Animation/Anime Reviews Film/TV Interviews Film/TV News Film/TV Review
ronnie coleman
Become a King with a Free Gym Pass – Ronnie Coleman: The King Review

A long, long time ago before IG fitness models were a thing,...

netflix anime
New Anime Series for Netflix Starting this Fall

Netflix announced two new anime series during the Netflix Anime panel at...

zombie land saga
From the Creators of Yuri on Ice, Zombie Land Saga

TLDR Cygames announced an all new anime, Zombie Land Saga, at...

Event News Event Reviews
Blizzard SDCC 2018
Blizzard SDCC 2018 – Blizzard Entertainment Brings Massive Lineup to SDCC

Blizzard in SDCC 2018 – Blizzard Entertainment brings Overwatch, StarCraft, and...

Nuclear Blast SDCC 2018
Nuclear Blast SDCC 2018 – Nuclear Blast Teams Up with JSR and Stern Pinball

Nuclear Blast SDCC 2018 – Nuclear Blast Teams Up with JSR...

Anime expo 2018
Anime Expo 2018 Brings the Heat to Los Angeles

Last year, I picked on Anime Expo not being worth the...

Enabled Gaming Gaming News Gaming Reviews
Jurassic Park: The Chaos Gene
Mondo Games Unleashes Jurassic Park: The Chaos Gene Board Game

MONDO GAMES unleashes Jurassic Park: The Chaos Gene board game for 25th Anniversary...

Great Coffee Break
Escape Work By Playing The Great Coffee Break

You can escape work, in more ways than one, by playing The...

Marvel Contest of Champions Battlerealm Review
Marvel Contest of Champions Battlerealm Review

Upper Deck’s Marvel Contest of Champions Battlerealm Review – Travel the...

Comic Creator Interviews Comic/Graphic Novel News Comic/Graphic Novel Reviews Manga News Manga Reviews Novel/Novella Author Interviews Novel/Novella News Novel/Novella Reviews
Batman / The Maxx: Arkham Dreams
Sam Kieth Makes Long-Awaited Return to The Outback in Batman / The Maxx: Arkham Dreams

SAN DIEGO, CA and BURBANK, CA (June 21, 2018) – Batman...

Wrestling Writer Legends Bill Apter & Gary Morgenstein Announce, ‘The Last Wrestler’

To names that are synonymous with professional wrestling journalism and well...

thousand year beach
The Thousand Year Beach – Viz Media Debuts Acclaimed Sci-Fi Novel

“The Thousand Year Beach presents an idyllic virtual world, still running...

Apparel/Personal Maintenance News Apparel/Personal Maintenance Reviews Entertainment Product News Entertainment Product Reviews Food/Beverage Reviews Hardware News Hardware Reviews Mystery Box News Mystery Box Reviews
heaven's feel
Fate/stay night [Heaven’s Feel] THE MOVIE I. presage flower Blu-ray Release

TLDR Aniplex of America announced that box office hit, Fate/stay night ...

Few Even Come Close – EVEN H2 Headphones Review

Even headphones are like having prescription glasses, but for your ears...

Black Widow Ozobot Skin
Learn the Code, then Break It With The Ozobot Black Widow Skin

Hands down the most fun anyone can have learning to code...

Arena Football Automotives MMA, Kick Boxing & Boxing Professional Wrestling
NJPW G1 Special from San Francisco Results

New Japan Pro Wrestling (NJPW) the King of Sports returns to...

Jeanie Buss & MGM TV Tags AXS TV to Broadcast WOW-Women of Wrestling Events

Jeanie Buss and MGM Television Tags AXS TV to Broadcast WOW-Women...

Kevin Belington Faces Martin Nguyen for the ONE FC Interim Bantamweight Title

From ONE FC – 07 June 2018 – Manila, Philippines: The...

Adult Continuity Comics on the Can Cultural Junk Drawer Future Comic Rock Stars Is That Racist? Revisiting the Reviled THAT'S NOT ROTTEN! The B-Reel The Cantina Scene This Week in Crowdfunding What the HELL Did I just...?
Harlan Ellison: A tribute (of sorts)

For the longest time in my life I was afraid of...

Iron Fist Racist
Is Marvel Iron Fist Racist? Part 2- Yeah…

After the casting controversy, two shows, and a guest appearance in Marvel...

Cultural Junkdrawer – Season’s end: The Flash season 4


Gaming Uncensored Toon-In-Talk
Gaming Uncensored: Year in Review 2016

A look back at the year in gaming. Related

Gaming Uncensored Roundtable: December 2016

December’s roundtable discusses story in games with Chad, Josh, and Spencer....

Gaming Uncensored: Podcast #349

Jamie reflects on some of his time with the HTC Vive....

Music Interviews Music News Music Reviews
Crisis on Earth-X Soundtrack
Blake Neely Behind-the-Scenes Recording of Crisis on Earth-X Soundtrack

Check out this exclusive Behind-The-Scenes video with Blake Neely as he...

Rising Country Music Artist Kaylin Roberson Talks About her work with St. Jude

Kaylin Roberson is a singer, songwriter and pianist from Raleigh, North...

MTV Unveils Performers for ‘TRL Live’ on October 3rd at 3 p.m. E.T.

NEW YORK, NY (September 26, 2017) – MTV today announced that...

%d bloggers like this: